Saturday, June 7, 2014

Adoption and the Pro-Life Debate

Adoption and the “Pro-Life” Debate

There are nights I cannot sleep.  My “mamma bear” instinct surges and I cannot get pictures of these children out of my head.  I see them, emaciated, starving, disheveled, vacant stares void of any emotion or human connection.  They languish in orphanages or institutions; some are lucky enough to be in state administered foster families, but they are few and far between.  These are the roughly 153,000,000 orphans in our world.  Reliable statistics are hard to come by.  The United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) defines an orphan as “a child who has lost one or both parents” (UNICEF, 2008).  Certainly, this definition is broad, and contributes to the ambiguity of statistics surrounding international orphans.  Some children are abandoned, others placed for adoption by a parent without the other’s knowledge due to that parent’s absence or abandonment.  These statistics put forth by UNICEF and other global organizations do not take into account children who are trafficked or sold. 

I become enraged when I think of these children and how they have been left; how they are treated.  How they are judged for physical disabilities, chronic health conditions, or conditions such as fetal alcohol syndrome and neonatal abstinence syndrome-things they didn’t ask for and they certainly don’t deserve.  Why do we not do more?  Why are we not lining up in droves?  After all, we have plenty of people in this country and throughout the world who demand that these children be brought to term and birthed regardless of circumstance or socioeconomic constraint.  Thus, we have the “adoption and pro-life debate.”

“Choose life!”  It’s the rallying cry of the pro-life, anti-abortion movement.  “The baby didn’t ask you to get pregnant.”  “Don’t punish the baby for your mistake.”  “Every life God places in the womb is sacred.”  I’ve heard it all.  And how many of my friends and acquaintances who spout these phrases with sanctimonious disdain have an adopted child?  A child whose mother “chose life?”  Zero.  None of them.  Why?  After all, these mothers have birthed these children as they were berated to do.  Often alone, indigent and horribly unprepared and frightened, they deliver their children in their homes, on the street, in a field; sometimes they make it to a hospital.  That is, if they can pay their bills or even be admitted.  There are no EMTALA laws in Russia, the Ukraine, remote parts of Africa and the Caribbean.  You’re not privileged?  Married?  Have a family member or spouse who can bribe the administration for your care?  The remote “hospital” where you showed up doesn’t have a spare room much less supplies to safely deliver you of your child?  Sorry, you’re out of luck.  Facing no other options, these women place their children for adoption.  They love them fiercely, and they make the ultimate sacrifice as women and mothers.  They leave them on orphanage steps, they leave them in public spaces such as markets and subways where they know the child will be found, and they fervently pray that a family will come along who can care for them in ways that they would never fathom being able to.

In much of the preparation we are doing to prepare for our own adoption, my husband and I read books, watch documentaries and pour over resources.  In one particularly poignant and stirring documentary, “China’s Lost Girls”, adopted Chinese girls are interviewed along with their adoptive parents.  These girls unanimously express love and gratitude to their birth mothers.  They know that the quantity and quality of their lives in China would have been drastically diminished.  They now have ample opportunities for success, and enjoy meaningful and sustained relationships with their parents and their peers, all while honoring their culture and heritage.  This documentary also provides an in depth look at the societocultural barriers to keeping a child once a woman finds out they are pregnant.  “One child” laws and a patriarchal society which devalues females and demeans their potential for contributions to society all make pregnancy dangerous and stressful for many of China’s pregnant women.  Add to that the stress of being in the peasant class with limited to no resources and no ability to care for yourself much less a child, and we now see the contributing factors to China’s orphan crisis.

Let’s return to the “pro-life” debate and the word of God.  They often go hand in hand, and I want to address that.  I am a devout, Christian woman.  I actively practice my faith.  My husband and I are raising our daughter to know the powerful, joyful and all-encompassing love of God.  We are teaching her (and we both strive) to live our lives as a testimony to our faith by our thoughts, words and deeds.  We are by no means perfect, but we try.  I often hear pro-life people recite these passages and many others from scripture:

Jeremiah 1:5:  “Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you...”
Matthew 19:14:  “Let the children come to me…”
Psalms 22:9-10:  “From my mother’s womb you have been my God…”

Let’s look at some other scripture, however.  Let’s look at what God commands us to do for these 153,000,000 orphans around the world.  Let’s look at how he is ordering us to act.

James 1:27:  “Look after orphans and widows in their distress…”
Ephesians 1:5:  “He predestined us for adoption through Jesus Christ…”
Proverbs 24:12:  “Once our eyes are opened, we cannot pretend we do not know what to do…”

And my personal favorite…

Matthew 5:16:  “Let your light shine before others that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in heaven.”

The message is clear.  I implore you to examine your personal thoughts, biases and concerns about adoption.  If you are pro-life, think about the contradiction of demanding birth and life, but then not doing anything to fight for that child’s quality of life.  Look at these pictures.  Look at them.  Do they make your gut churn?  Do you want to turn away?  Do you cry?  Do you hug your child a bit harder and longer tonight because you are so thankful that they don’t live this way?  Good.  I’m glad you’re uncomfortable.  I’m glad they upset you.  They’re supposed to. 

I tell you now, it is not enough to simply say, “Praise God that this child was born.”  “I’m so glad he’s at least alive.” There is suffering in this world.  There is starvation, abuse and neglect of the highest and most atrocious forms.  There are children who need families, love, prayer and support.  There are children who need us.  They need food, shelter, clothing and other things that are at the bottom of Maslow’s pyramid.  They need a family to love them, to celebrate them and to tell them there are no monsters under the bed, that their lunch will be packed perfectly the next day with the crusts cut off their sandwich, and that their artwork is the most amazing, innovative art their parents have ever seen. 

You are pro-life?  You want to see a change?  Be the agent of change God demands you to be.  Show his love, his faithfulness and his mercy to those who have been forgotten on the margins of society.  Show the world that collectively we are stronger than the evils of corruption, discrimination, inequality and attempts at eugenics and invasive family planning.

It is not enough to speak.  It is not enough to rest comfortably in our wealth, our excess and our comforts. 

You must do.


"Sometimes I would like to ask God why he allows poverty, famine and injustice in the world, when He could do something about it...but I'm afraid He may ask me the same question."                                                           Anonymous

1 comment:

  1. I think you should write a book. Just on tbe world according to Kathleen. Things you care about and your opinions. I think itd be really good! Id read it lol

    ReplyDelete